S&P Global Inc. should “carefully consider” a proposed tweak to how it assesses the creditworthiness of bonds owned by insurance companies, the Justice Department said, warning that such a change “could raise significant concerns” under U.S. antitrust law.
The Justice Department’s antitrust division said in a letter dated last Friday that a proposed methodology change by S&P — the world’s largest credit ratings company — could raise barriers for its rivals. The changes could end up hurting the credit grades of insurance companies that invest in bonds that aren’t rated by S&P.
The firm should “carefully consider whether penalizing insurers that purchase securities rated by S&P’s competitors has the potential to raise barriers to entry and expansion by competitors, insulate S&P from competition, or otherwise suppress competition from rival rating agencies,” said antitrust chief in the . “Such actions could raise significant concerns that the Sherman Act has been — or will be — violated and warrant additional scrutiny.”
S&P is the No. 1 player in the U.S. market for credit ratings, which financial firms and investors use to measure the risk of products, companies or other entities. S&P controlled about 50 percent of the market as of December 2020, according to the Securities and Exchange Commission.
Late last year, S&P proposed changing for the first time in more than a decade how it measures the creditworthiness of insurance companies. The new method would put more weight on the bonds within a firm’s investment portfolio and rank bonds rated exclusively by its competitors as less creditworthy. In some cases, that would demote the bonds to junk status — or beneath investment grade.
Critics have said the proposed change would pressure bond issuers to do more business with S&P and possibly devalue the assets already held by insurers. The National Association of Insurance Commissioners — a standards group for commissioners of U.S. states and territories — raised its own concerns about the S&P methodology change in March, urging S&P to reconsider.
S&P said in a statement Wednesday it would carefully review and consider the DOJ’s comment in its criteria development process, which it said is focused on “analytical quality.” S&P said its “policies and procedures provide a framework that supports our analysts in operating independently of commercial considerations and influence.”
Photo: Jonathan Kanter; Photographer: Win McNamee/Getty Images
Topics Carriers
Was this article valuable?
Here are more articles you may enjoy.
Worst Start to Wildfire Season Raises Alarm as El Ni帽o Threatens 
Spirit Airlines Shuts Down After 34 Years, Blames Higher Oil Prices 
Florida Governor Signs Bill Dropping Building Permits for Work Valued at $7,500 or Less 
Hedge Funds Make Their Move as Litigation Finance Assets Slump 
